Knowledge

Flat fee or commission? Compare music distribution costs over three years

Compare the fee base, number of releases and renewals over the same term. A distributor with a lower headline price can cost more for a growing catalogue. The following plans and figures are fictional, not current provider quotes.

Calculate the point where one plan becomes cheaper

Plan A costs £60 a year with no share of the specified recording receipts; three years cost £180. Plan B charges £35 once per release and takes 10% of the same receipts. On one release, the three-year fee equals Plan A at £1,450 of receipts: (£180 less £35) divided by 10%.

For £600 of receipts, Plan B costs £95 and Plan A £180. For £3,000 of receipts, Plan B costs £335 and Plan A £180. Use the same three-year gross-to-distributor revenue base in each case. Do not put composition income or artist cash after deductions in only one denominator.

Account for the catalogue and the exit

If two more releases are added to Plan B at £35 each and Plan A genuinely includes them, Plan B has £105 in upfront charges and its crossover drops to £750. If Plan A charges for more artists, expedited delivery, collections or long-term availability, put those fees in as separate lines instead of treating the price as fixed.

Before switching, check contract renewals, re-delivery and offer expiry; payout minimums and when the money becomes usable; whether payments such as social, YouTube or store add-ons share a different rate; and what happens to the release and unpaid balances at exit. Build downside, central and upside receipts without assuming a per-stream rate.

Figures referred to

One-release three-year crossoverIllustrative
£1,450 of qualifying receiptsFictional worked example in this guide · as of 2026-11
Three-release crossover on the same termsIllustrative
£750 of qualifying receiptsFictional worked example in this guide · as of 2026-11

Figures marked Illustrative show the shape of the market, not a quoted rate. The lessons keep the maintained, sourced numbers.

Primary sources

Common questions

Is a subscription plan always cheaper after the artist starts earning?

No. It depends on the applicable revenue base, catalogue size, renewals and additional fees.

Learn this properly

The interactive lessons on this topic, with sourced figures and live simulators: